---
title: "Stem Cells vs PRP vs Cortisone vs Gel Shots: An Honest Comparison of Knee Arthritis Injections"
description: "An honest comparison of knee arthritis injections: cortisone, hyaluronic acid, PRP and mesenchymal stem cells. What each does, what trials show, how long relief lasts, cost, and how to choose."
canonical: "https://dreambody.clinic/stem-cells-vs-prp-vs-cortisone-knee-arthritis/"
---

# Stem Cells vs PRP vs Cortisone vs Gel Shots: An Honest Comparison of Knee Arthritis Injections

If you live with knee osteoarthritis, you’ve probably heard about more than one kind of injection. Your doctor may have offered a cortisone shot. A friend swears by “gel shots.” A sports clinic down the road advertises platelet-rich plasma (PRP). And you’ve found clinics, including ours, that offer mesenchymal stem cell (MSC) therapy.

They’re very different treatments, with different goals, different costs and very different amounts of research behind them. This guide compares the four most common knee injections side by side, explains what the best available trials actually show, and helps you think through which questions matter for your knee. It isn’t meant to sell you on one option. Ideally, you’ll use it to have a better conversation with your own doctor.

## The Four Injections at a Glance

|  | Cortisone (corticosteroid) | Hyaluronic acid (“gel shots”) | PRP (platelet-rich plasma) | Mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| **What it is** | A powerful anti-inflammatory steroid | A lubricating gel similar to natural joint fluid | A concentrate of your own blood platelets | Living cells that release signaling molecules |
| **Main goal** | Fast, short-term pain relief | Lubrication and modest pain relief | Pain relief through growth factors | Calming inflammation, possibly reducing pain and improving function |
| **Typical onset** | Days | Weeks | Weeks | Gradual; often over 3–6 months |
| **Strength of evidence** | Short-term relief is well established | Small average benefit in trials | Mixed: some trials positive, a large placebo-controlled trial negative | Modest pain and function improvements in trials; investigational |
| **Rebuilds cartilage?** | No | No | No good evidence | No consistent evidence |
| **FDA status in the US** | Approved | Approved (as a device) | Not approved for knee OA | Not approved; expanded MSCs not legally available |

## Cortisone: Fast Relief, Short-Lived

Cortisone shots are the most common knee injection, and for good reason: they often reduce pain and swelling within days. The 2019 American College of Rheumatology and Arthritis Foundation guideline strongly recommends steroid injections for knee osteoarthritis ([Kolasinski et al., Arthritis Care Res, 2020](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31908149/)).

The catch is that relief usually fades within weeks to a few months, and repeated shots may not be harmless. In a two-year randomized trial, 140 people with knee osteoarthritis received either a steroid injection or a salt-water (saline) injection every three months. The steroid group lost slightly more cartilage on MRI, and, by the end of two years, had no better pain than the saline group ([McAlindon et al., JAMA, 2017](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28510679/)). That doesn’t mean an occasional cortisone shot is wrong. It means it works best as a short-term tool, not a long-term plan.

**Why it matters if you’re considering MSCs:** steroids are strongly anti-inflammatory, and our physicians don’t treat a joint that’s had a steroid injection in the past three months. If you’re thinking about MSC therapy, mention any recent or planned cortisone shots at your consultation.

## Hyaluronic Acid ("Gel Shots"): Small Average Benefit

Hyaluronic acid is a natural part of joint fluid, and injections are meant to add lubrication and cushioning. They’re usually given as one to five shots, and some people say their knee feels smoother for several months.

The research is less impressive than the marketing. A large review of 89 trials covering more than 12,000 patients found that the average pain benefit was small and probably not clinically meaningful, with a slightly higher risk of side effects such as flares ([Rutjes et al., Ann Intern Med, 2012](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22868835/)). The 2019 ACR guideline conditionally recommends against them for the knee ([Kolasinski et al., 2020](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31908149/)). Some people still report real relief, which is a reminder that averages don’t describe every individual.

## PRP: Promising, but the Trials Disagree

PRP is made by drawing your blood, spinning it in a centrifuge, and injecting the platelet-rich portion into the knee. Platelets carry growth factors, and the idea is that concentrating them may calm pain and inflammation.

PRP is probably the most debated knee injection right now:

- **A large, well-run trial was negative.** In the RESTORE trial, 288 people with knee osteoarthritis received three PRP or three saline injections. After 12 months, PRP didn’t reduce pain or slow cartilage loss more than saline did ([Bennell et al., JAMA, 2021](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34812863/)).
- **Pooled trials look more positive, but uncertain.** A 2026 analysis of 20 placebo-controlled trials found PRP improved pain and function compared with placebo at 6 and 12 months, but rated the certainty of that evidence as very low, partly because PRP preparations vary so much from one clinic to the next ([Delgado et al., Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc, 2026](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/42605960/)).

The ACR guideline recommends against PRP for knee osteoarthritis, largely because of how inconsistent the preparations and results are ([Kolasinski et al., 2020](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31908149/)).

## Mesenchymal Stem Cells: Modest Benefits, Still Investigational

MSCs are studied mainly for how they influence the tissue around them. Much of their effect is thought to come from **paracrine signaling**, the release of growth factors and signaling molecules that may help regulate inflammation and support the body’s own repair processes. They’re not thought to work mainly by turning into new cartilage.

Here’s what the best current research shows:

- **Pain and function: modest improvement.** A 2026 review pooled 28 randomized trials of MSC injections for knee osteoarthritis. On average, MSCs improved pain and several measures of daily function compared with control injections, although some scoring systems showed no difference ([Awad et al., Clin Rheumatol, 2026](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41863718/)).
- **Structure: no consistent change.** In the same review, MRI scores didn’t improve consistently. The authors concluded that MSC injections appear to relieve symptoms rather than rebuild the joint.
- **Side effects: more local soreness, few serious problems.** Injection-site pain and joint swelling were about two to three times more common after MSCs than after control injections. Serious complications such as infection were uncommon.
- **Umbilical cord cells specifically: early and mixed.** A 2025 review of eight trials of umbilical cord-derived MSCs, the closest cell type to ours, found no statistically significant pain reduction overall, though some measures and some dose groups improved and side effects were mild ([Lohrasbi et al., Stem Cells Int, 2025](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41378180/)).

Different trials used different cell sources, doses and techniques, and many used patients’ own bone marrow or fat rather than donated umbilical cord tissue, so results from one approach can’t simply be applied to another. MSC therapy for knee osteoarthritis is investigational and isn’t FDA-approved. The fair summary is that some patients report meaningful improvement in pain and function, results vary, and some see little or no benefit.

## So Which One Is "Best"?

There isn’t one right answer for everyone. A few honest principles help:

- **No injection rebuilds a worn-out knee.** None of the four has strong evidence for regrowing cartilage. Be wary of any clinic that promises otherwise.
- **Placebo effects in knee pain are large.** In both the steroid and PRP trials above, the saline groups improved too. That’s why randomized, placebo-controlled trials matter, and why a friend’s great result, while real for them, can’t predict yours.
- **Match the tool to the goal.** If you need fast relief for an upcoming trip or event, cortisone may make sense. If you’re hoping for gradual, longer-term change and are comfortable with an investigational option, MSC therapy may be worth discussing. If you’re already near the end stage, a surgeon’s opinion about knee replacement is worth having. Knee replacement is an established, effective operation for many people with severe arthritis.
- **Think about sequence.** Because recent steroid injections affect whether and when we can treat, it helps to plan ahead rather than stacking treatments.

## How Our Knee Protocol Works

Our [stem cell knee treatment](https://dreambody.clinic/stem-cell-knee-treatment/) is a single ultrasound-guided injection of 50 million MSCs into the knee joint. The cells come from Wharton’s jelly (umbilical cord tissue) and placenta donated after healthy births, and they’re expanded in our own on-site laboratory, which holds three COFEPRIS licenses (Mexico’s federal health regulator). Cells are grown in a GMP-grade, xeno-free medium in a cleanroom, tested by COFEPRIS-authorized third-party labs, taken out of culture the day before your procedure and given within 24 hours. Details are on our [certified stem cells page](https://dreambody.clinic/certified-stem-cells/).

We don’t currently add PRP to the knee protocol.

The all-inclusive price is **$3,500 USD for one knee** or **$7,000 for both knees on the same trip**. That covers an on-site open MRI, a full blood panel, the physician consultation, the cells and the injection. Plan to stay in the Puerto Vallarta area for about five days. Payment happens only after our physician reviews your MRI with you. If the MRI shows you’re not a good candidate, you pay only for the MRI ($500) and blood panel ($300), and we’ll explain why.

Treatment may not go ahead if your MRI shows complete tears, large bone spurs or very advanced joint damage, if you’ve had a steroid injection in the past three months, or if you’ve had cancer in the past five years. After treatment, we give you a four-week rehab program and follow up remotely at 3, 6 and 12 months. Many patients who respond notice changes gradually, with the most change often reported around three to six months.

## Frequently Asked Questions

**Can I have a cortisone shot before stem cell treatment?** Our physicians don’t treat a joint that’s had a steroid injection in the past three months, so tell us about any recent or planned shots. Your own doctor and ours can help you plan the timing. Never stop or change a prescription medication, especially prednisone, without talking to the doctor who prescribed it.

**I’ve had gel shots. Can I still be a candidate?** Usually, yes. Previous hyaluronic acid injections don’t by themselves rule you out. Our physicians will ask about all prior injections at your consultation.

**Is PRP the same as stem cell therapy?** No. PRP is a concentrate of your own blood platelets, which carry growth factors. It doesn’t contain cultured stem cells. MSC therapy uses living cells that have been grown in a laboratory.

**Are stem cells better than PRP?** There are very few trials comparing them head to head, and both have mixed evidence. We’d rather tell you that honestly than claim one is clearly superior.

**Will any of these injections help me avoid knee replacement?** None has been proven to prevent or replace surgery. Some people find an injection gives them enough relief to delay a decision, and that’s a reasonable goal to discuss with your doctor. If surgery is clearly the better option, we’ll tell you.

**Why are stem cell injections more expensive?** Growing, testing and delivering living cells takes a licensed laboratory and a lot more work than preparing a steroid, gel or PRP injection. Our price also includes an MRI and a blood panel.

**Are these injections covered by insurance?** Cortisone and, in some cases, hyaluronic acid are often covered in the US. PRP and MSC therapy usually aren’t. Check with your insurer.

## Not Sure Which Option Fits You?

If you’ve tried an injection or two and you’re wondering what makes sense next, we’re happy to talk it through. A free consultation is just a conversation: we’ll listen to your history, review your records, and tell you plainly whether we think MSC therapy is reasonable for your knee, or whether something else might suit you better.

**[Schedule your free consultation](https://dreambody.clinic/contact/)**, call (888) 704-3977, WhatsApp +52 322 232 1055, or email info@dreambodyclinic.net.

---

*Disclaimer: This article is for educational purposes and is not medical advice. Mesenchymal stem cell therapy for knee osteoarthritis is investigational and is not approved by the U.S. FDA. Results vary, and some patients see little or no benefit. Treatment is provided in Mexico at a COFEPRIS-licensed facility. Please consult your physician before making treatment decisions.*
